!! OMG, his butt: Evan Peters !! » Posted By Phillip On Thursday, October 18, 2012 | category: Candy | 4 comments And so it begins. American Horror Story‘s Evan Peters is already getting naked for the show’s second season, re-imagined from the first season’s murder house into a long-haunted asylum. After the jump, see NSFW stills of Peters’ butt as the actor (now a brunette instead of blond) is shamelessly hosed off.